8 Reasons Not to Ban the Pitbull ...

8 Reasons Not to Ban the Pitbull ...
By Melanie • Sep 16, 2010 MD

Punish the deed, not the breed. That’s the motto I like to stick to when it comes to the B.S.L (Breed Selective Legislation). Under the B.S.L, they are trying to ban “dangerous” breeds, such as the pitbull. Seriously, this is the most hideous thing I have ever heard of. I thought we lived in a country where being racist is wrong, yet people turn around and try to ban certain breeds. It doesn’t make sense. Look at my site and you will find some information on pitbulls – myths busted - pitbulllove.yolasite.com . Right now, I am going to give you 8 reasons not to ban the pitbull.

8. They’re Good Family Dogs

They’re Good Family Dogs Photo Credit: e k p

Point blank, they make good family dogs. They’re fun to play with and they’re loving. They listen to commands. Yeah, that’s the problem. They are so loyal that they listen to anything their owner tells them.

***

Pitbulls are bursting with energy and affection making them wonderful companions for children who need a playful pal. Their protective nature also makes them excellent watchdogs, ensuring the safety and security of your loved ones. With proper training and socialization, they can show an incredible capacity for gentleness and patience, seamlessly integrating into the fabric of a family unit. They simply reflect the care and guidance they receive, much like a mirror of their owner's intentions. Consistent and positive reinforcement is key to nurturing their innate qualities.

Thinking...

Please leave your email and we’ll get back to you on that.

7. So Many Good Families Have Them

So Many Good Families Have Them Photo Credit: staceyviera

Do you know how many good families in the United States own a pitbull? If you were to ban them, you would be taking away people’s dogs. Wait, what am I saying, they have already done this in some areas. It’s sad to watch a child cry as their dog was being taken away. To that child “your dog was taken away and killed because of his breed.” Wow, what does that teach them about racism?

***

What a harsh lesson for a youngster that love doesn't triumph over prejudice. Pitbulls in nurturing homes demonstrate daily they're as loving and loyal as any other breed. These families have raised their pitbulls with care, only to face the gut-wrenching possibility that their innocent, cherished pet might be legally seized. Their pitbull, a furry family member who's never shown aggression, suddenly judged solely by appearance. This misguided viewpoint doesn't just penalize the dog, but it emotionally devastates all those who considered that dog a crucial part of their family unit. The trauma inflicted is both needless and profound.

Thinking...

Please leave your email and we’ll get back to you on that.

6. They’re the American Icon

They’re the American Icon Photo Credit: jcolman

Yeah, they are an American icon whether you like it or not. Stubby, a pitbull served in a war and saved lives. This breed has saved lives, why do they not get the respect and dignity that they deserve? Yet, little dogs who have done nothing get all the praise.

***

Pitbulls have etched their place in American culture, not just as pets but as loyal companions who have, time and again, proved their mettle. Sergeant Stubby, an example of sheer bravery, is a historic figure who not only served with soldiers but also acted as a mascot for American troops during World War I. Despite this rich legacy, the breed often faces unwarranted stigma and generalization. It's time we recognized their contributions and judged them for their individual behavior rather than breed-based stereotypes.

Thinking...

Please leave your email and we’ll get back to you on that.

5. The Ban Doesn’t Stop Dog Bites

The Ban Doesn’t Stop Dog Bites Photo Credit: efprince

It’s a proven fact. This little ban people are trying to place will not stop dog bites. Statistics have even showed this. Just like putting a killer in prison, it does not stop other killers. OTHER dogs bite.

***

Proponents of these bans fail to recognize that dog bite incidents aren't breed-specific issues but rather individual animal behavior problems, often stemming from poor ownership or training practices. No particular breed is innately vicious. In fact, responsible ownership and proper socialization are key to preventing bites. The focus should be on promoting responsible pet ownership irrespective of breed. Moreover, targeting a single breed creates a false sense of security, potentially ignoring the risks posed by other breeds not included in the ban. The solution lies in educating about all dog behaviors and enforcing general safety measures, rather than ineffective breed-specific legislation.

Thinking...

Please leave your email and we’ll get back to you on that.

Sunshine and blue skies bring positivity and joy and it's important for every woman to take full advantage of it. Even when stuck indoors, it's still possible to enjoy some good vibes. Check out these unique tips on how to make the most of the weather right at your home. Let's celebrate every beautiful day, no matter where we are.

4. Innocent Dogs Will Die

I was looking through pictures online the other night and I really do regret it. I have horrible images of these beautiful dogs piled on top of each other … dead. Why? Because the B.S.L was approved in the area they lived in. They took innocent dogs from their owners and killed them. That is sick. It’s wrong and not right.

***

Many of these dogs were family pets, with no history of aggression. They were beloved companions, their only crime being their breed. Regulations failed to consider individual temperament and history. Imagine the anguish of these pet owners, forced to surrender their loyal friends, only to know the heartbreak of their brutal fate. The law delivered a cruel judgment, ripping apart bonds between humans and their cherished pets. This lack of compassion and justice flies in the face of what it means to be a civilized society. It's not only about the dogs; it's about our humanity being tarnished.

Thinking...

Please leave your email and we’ll get back to you on that.

3. It’s the Owners They Should Look at

It’s the Owners They Should Look at Photo Credit: woofslc

Punish the deed, not the breed! Who makes them do the deed? The owners do. I repeat, it is the owners fault! Yeah, yeah, go and say you did nothing but love the dog and it turned on you– I DO NOT believe you. There is something you must have done wrong – even if it was leave the child alone with the dog. Dogs can only take so much. They do not like to be pulled on – children shouldn’t even be left alone with a small dog.

Thinking...

Please leave your email and we’ll get back to you on that.

2. It’s Wrong

It’s Wrong Photo Credit: ambermarie9187

Why would you want to ban the pit bull or any other breed for that matter? Don’t you think it is wrong? Who are we to sit there and say they are not allowed to live on Earth? We’re not God.

***

Banning a breed based on misconceptions and stereotypes isn't just unfair; it's morally questionable. Each dog, like a human, has an individual personality and character, molded by their upbringing, training, and environment. Sweeping judgments are an injustice to the countless pit bulls that have shown themselves to be loving, loyal, and gentle companions. Who are we to strip away the rights of a living creature based solely on its breed? It's a slippery slope when we start making decisions that undermine the intrinsic value of life in all its forms.

Thinking...

Please leave your email and we’ll get back to you on that.

1. It’s a Form of Racism

It’s a Form of Racism Photo Credit: erinkejo

Some people walk around ranting about racism, then those same people go and sign petitions to have pitbulls banned. How hypocritical is this? This is a form of racism. Wanting to ban one breed just because of their name. Why not ban all little dogs? They bite just as much. Why not ban owners who teach the dogs wrong things? Why not ban humans – humans do stupid things, they kill people – shouldn’t that all make us look bad? What gives us the right?

I know that I was a little blunt in this blog, but I’m tired of all the pit haters out there. I don’t really understand how someone can be so hateful. Those are my 8 reasons not to ban the pitbull. I am sure, there will be posts on here of how they were bitten by a pitbull or how they should be banned, but I don’t care to hear that you want them banned. If you say it, then you are racist. What I do want to hear is your happy experience with your dog. Let these dogs shine, let people see that they are heroes and have been for a very long time. Let’s pull together and make this blog a positive place for pitbulls.

Top Photo Credit: MelanieFitzpatrick

Feedback Junction

Where Thoughts and Opinions Converge

  • Stephanie

    2010-09-26T19:03:58.000Z

    Ok, so I don't have a pit bull type dog but I've been around many of them and they were very nice dogs. I do have terriers, tiny toy terriers and they will try to attack anything around non-human. Most of this is my fault for failure to properly socialize them but some of this is because terriers were bred to kill things. Rats, mice, snakes, etc. This does not mean they are bad dogs or that they should be banned. Some of them don't have a very high prey drive and some have such a high prey drive they cannot be around fish (my rat terrier cried for days and tried to jump up to get a betta). Dogs should not be banned unless they become a danger to humans. My dogs are not out and about, I have a fenced yard and they only rarely get to go on walks because they get too wound up. I do not allow them around other animals because they can be aggressive. If you get into the debate on why a certain breed should be banned then you are going to eventually move into the territory that another breed can be dangerous and should be banned and then another. ALL dogs can be dangerous, even Chihuahuas and Pomeranians. A child was killed by a Pomeranian and a cop was attacked by a pack of 5 Chihuahuas, Google it. We should not ban them just because they CAN be dangerous but put down the ones who ARE dangerous. Cars can be incredibly dangerous, but no one would ever think of banning automobiles. Why? Because they're too useful. Dogs are too useful to ban also, they sniff for bombs, find people trapped beneath rubble, sniff out cancer now . . . the list goes on and on. Anyway, that's just my 2 cents worth. If you hate pit bulls nothing is probably going to change your mind anyway, but I think they're great. I won't have one though because I think it's unfair to have a larger dog with tiny ones in case a fight does break out and with my little aggressors, I know eventually one would. :(
  • Katy

    2016-01-18T18:34:16.678Z

    Many dog breeds have attacked people and they aren't illegal in some states or anything like that. Why only pitbulls?
  • ChatBoheme

    2010-09-17T09:59:08.000Z

    Not quite Pitbull, but my housemate owns a Staff and while walking her I had people move to the other side of the street. Every now and again I am tempted to think 'she's a staff.. I should be more careful around her'.. but she's like a cute old lady and once she's around me I don't worry at all.. she's so sweet. And she lives with two cats that torture her on a daily basis and she does nothing about it.. she's so calm and sweet. :) Of course I wouldn't trust any random staff on the street.. or pitbull for that matter. ;)
  • maz

    2010-09-16T09:18:58.000Z

    i agree with you, ive heard things about pitbulls biting other dogs and even kids, but ive heard just as many stories about other dogs, if you want to ban these dogs for biting, youd have to ban every other dog as well
  • Shay

    2010-09-16T19:15:27.000Z

    Grace, I'm sorry about what happened to your cat, I understand how devestating the loss of a pet can be, but don't judge all pits just because of what this one pit bull did. The pit bull did not attack your cat because it was deliberately trying to hurt your family. It's in the dog's nature, it's in a LOT of breeds' nature. Here's something everybody should know, first of all Pit bulls are a part of the terrier family, and ALL terriers (Yorkies, Jack Russell, etc.) are NOT friendly towards other animals, normally, so if you have a cat, or another animal, it is both YOUR RESPONSIBILITY AND THE OWNER'S to keep your pets away from eachother. Just because the pitbull is not necessarily ANIMAL friendly does NOT make it human aggressive. In fact, human agression is NOT, I repeat, NOT a trait the pit bull normally has. Pit Bulls are one of the most stable people-friendly dogs in existence. The National Canine Temperament Testing Association tested 122 breeds, and Pit Bulls placed the 4th highest with a 95% passing rate. They DO NOT turn on their owners, in fact no breed of dog actually does, Dog aggression is nearly ALWAYS preceded by some kind of warning, and there is ALWAYS a reason behind the attack. However, many inexperienced owners do not recognize the dog's behavior as aggression, or refuse to acknowledge it as a warning sign. The only exception to this is "Springer Rage", which is a neurological condition that manifests itself as a spontaneous attack, followed by confusion, and then a return to normal behavior. Pit Bulls are NOT prone to this condition. Obviously, there are individual dogs of ANY breed that are more aggressive than others. If you own a pitbull, or any other type of dog, you must be sure to train it, again it is the OWNER'S responsibility to make sure their dog knows right from wrong. The fact is, Pit Bulls are WONDERFUL dogs. They are intelligent, loving, and loyal. Many are used as service/ therapy dogs. Petey, the dog from The Little Rascals spent countless hours with children every day and never hurt anyone. They are good pets and should not be banned!
  • Grace

    2010-09-16T15:35:05.000Z

    you may love your pitbull and all, but these posts on how loving they are really should stop. A pitbull killed my family's cat and tried to injure one of our neighbors. The pitbull was our neighbors and they always treated the dog well and i even dog sitted several times and the dog was calm and even-tempered, however they are inherently dangerous and can snap at any moment. I would NEVER have one of these dogs around my house, let alone my children.
  • scott

    2013-02-19T03:08:50.000Z

    The combination of large molosser breeds, including pit bulls, rottweilers, presa canarios, cane corsos, mastiffs, dogo argentinos, fila brasieros, and their mixes: 79% of attacks that induce bodily harm 72% of attacks to children 85% of attack to adults 69% of attacks that result in fatalities 77% that result in maiming Discussion notes: Even if the pit bull category was "split four ways," attacks by pit bulls and their closest relatives would still outnumber attacks by any other breed. Pit bulls are noteworthy for attacking adults almost as frequently as children. This is a very rare pattern, only seen elsewhere in the bullmastiff/presa canario line. If a pit bull or rottweiler has a bad moment, instead of being bitten, often someone is maimed or killed; that has now created off-the-chart actuarial risk. 1982-2012 chart Breed Bodily harm Child Victims Adult Victims Deaths Maimings % of dog population Pit bull 2235 911 806 233 1268 4.4% Rottweiler 495 278 131 81 277 2.2% Husky 71 44 5 24 20 .05% Wolf hybrid 84 69 5 19 48 Bullmastiff (Presa canario) 87 30 33 14 46 .04% German shepherd 96 60 28 14 59 2.3% Pit bull-mix 148 63 37 12 83 Akita 65 42 19 8 47 .06% German shepherd-mix 41 26 12 7 26 Chow 55 36 16 7 37 .01% Doberman 15 8 7 7 7 1.3%
Commenting as

Keep exploring

Search AllWomenStalk for your next read.

Add allwomenstalk.com as a preferred source on Google to see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Allwomenstalk app icon

Don't Miss the Latest Version

Get the latest stories, save favorites, and share with friends — all in one place.

New Earn badges & level up while you read

Create your profile. Earn badges. Level up your reading.

Join Allwomenstalk to track your streaks, collect badges, and earn XP for the things you already do—reading, sharing, and taking quizzes.

  • 🔥
    Daily streaks with gentle boosts for 3, 7, and 30 days.
  • 🏅
    Collect badges like Reader I–III, Socialite, and Quiz Ace.
  • ⚡️
    Earn XP for reads, deep reads, likes, comments, and shares.

It’s free. Takes 30 seconds. Already have an account? Sign in.

10,000+ badges earned last month

Level

3

Streak

7 🔥

XP420 / 700

Badges

🔥 On a Roll
📖 Reader I
📣 Socialite

Trending products

Other Cool Reads

Related Topics

why do people go to the bar motorcycle insurance california is it worth fighting for a relationship proposal answer yes is rushing into a relationship bad married for the wrong reasons signs you should date your best friend wrong reasons to stay in a relationship 8 Reasons to Date a Man Older than You ... reasons to lie
Featured article image