Have you ever wondered how pro makeup artists produce that ‘smoky eyes‘ effect that women in Hollywood seem to effortlessly have all the time? Their trick is to use the best eyeliners in the market.
When buying eyeliners, choose one which is soft, works like liquid, glides like silk and has a pen-like body which is easy to control.
Check out AllWomenStalk’s picks for the best eyeliners in the market today.
1. Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyes
A two-in-one eyeshadow and liner pencil.
Experts opinion:
I’m obsessed with Make Up For Ever’s Aqua Eyes eyeliner. You can sweat, cry, swim, line the inside rims of your eyes and it will stay put. The color is really intense which makes this product a winner. It’s got a super soft texture so it glides on effortlessly.
- CINDY BOKMA, from California, US
Description:
Make-up Forever Aqua Eyes is a two-for-one product. It’s a combination of an eyeliner and an eyeshadow. What makes it unique is the formula which seems to stick forever to the eyelids – and as the testimonials indicate – you can even swim and the liner stays put!
Our Opinion:
We checked out the rest of the colors for this product, and there’s Pistachio, Majorelle, Fuchsia, Turquoise, Gold and a host of other shimmering colors! If you’re carrying a small evening purse, this is the perfect two-in-one makeup tool to bring – with the bonus of being an all-weather type of makeup.
Best Price: $16 at Sephora
2. Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil
A dynamic eye pencil, in a rainbow of shades.
Experts opinion:
The formula of all the 24/7’s are really wonderful – smooth and skip-proof going on, and they wear like iron. Need makeup remover to get them off, though.
- Amy, from Richmond, Virginia, US
Description:
As the name implies, the Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-on Pencil delightfully glides on color on the lining of your eyes. No matter which color it is that you will be choosing, they will delightfully blend to open up your eyes and create a base for the look that you want your makeup to have.
Our Opinion:
This is definitely a must-have in any makeup kit. What we like most about the glide-on pencil is the moisturizing ingredients and the waterproof formula, which feels really creamy when applied. The available colors are lovely, too!
Best Price: $16 at Sephora
3. Lancome LE STYLO WATERPROOF – Long Lasting Eyeliner
Eyeliner that is here to stay.
Experts opinion:
This waterproof pencil eyeliner has a unique twist tip that never needs sharpening. Won’t skip, smudge or streak. Available in 8 different colors.
- Agostina, makeup artist, from Los Angeles, US
Description:
The Le Stylo Eyeliner from LanCome has a unique tip which never needs sharpening. Also, as the name implies, the eyeliner is designed to withstand any type of weather – so it won’t skip, smudge or streak.
Our Opinion:
Lancome may be a pretty pricey brand – but this buy is definitely well worth it. What we love is the variety of colors that the eyeliners are available in. The rich formula glides ever so smoothly, the pencil does not ever need sharpening and the color stays with your eyes all day – what more can you ask for?
Best Price: $23.50 at Sephora
4. Smashbox Jet Set Waterproof Eye Liner
Waterproof, smudge-proof eye liner.
Experts opinion:
Out of all the eyeliner I’ve ever used, this one takes the cake when it comes to staying put and not smudging. It holds it’s ground when I’m washing and cleaning my face…The jar is made of glass and is about the diameter of a quarter. But don’t let it’s small size fool you, this tiny jar will last a very long time.
- Hello there Gorgeous,
Description:
Smashbox Jet Set is a waterproof eyeliner that is smudge-free. It comes in a gel formula which glides over your eyelids. There’s no need to pull or tug. Finally, the quick-dry formula is easy to apply-and-go. And the best news yet? It stays on all day!
Our Opinion:
As you can see, this eyeliner does not come as a pencil-like product. Instead, it comes in a container which has a gel-like, waterproof liner which can practically last you for a very long time! There are no eyeliner tips to sharpen and you can line the inner rim of your eye in one smooth motion.
Best Price: $22 at Sephora
5. Stila Convertible Eye Color
Versatile, dual-ended eye color wand.
Experts opinion:
Great for beginners! This was actually one of the first makeup items I purchased way back when. It’s also great for people on the go because you can line, smudge, and apply shadow all with this stick.
- Lily, from San Francisco, LA
Description:
The Stila Convertible eye color is a dual-ended wand which contains a smooth, easy-to-apply powder eyeshadow on one end. The other end conveniently contains an eyeliner pencil in a matching shade.
Our Opinion:
The result of the unique way that this product is packaged is that you don’t have to second guess which eyeshadow goes well with which eyeliner color. Those who are just beginning to experiment with the makeup that suits them best will have a blast with this product.
Best Price: $20 at Sephora
6. Hourglass Calligraphy Liquid Eye Liner
A moisturizing water and smudge-proof felt-tip liquid liner that contours and lines the eyes with precision.
Experts opinion:
The pen is easy to hold and control – which results in a precise, professional-looking line. And the water- and smudge-proof formula dries quickly to prevent streaks and smears. I’m not exaggerating, ladies…once applied, this liner ain’t going nowhere. But for all its staying power, it easily washes off with a few swipes of makeup remover.
- Daneen, makeup master, from Philly, PA,US
Description:
When choosing an eyeliner product to buy, one of the words that you should watch for is smudge-free. That’s exactly what you will get from the Hourglass Calligraphy liquid eyeliner. It’s way too easy to define your eyelids with this product, and the good news is that it stays on all day!
Our Opinion:
Remember that time when you had way too much time in your hands and you looked like a queen from Egypt because of the thickness of your eyeliner? The precise way that you can glide this moisturizing liquid liner on your eye will prevent any such makeup disaster from occurring again soon.
Best Price: $32 at Sephora
7. Clinique Quickliner for Eyes
An automatic eye pencil which twists up, glides on and smudges to a smooth blur of color.
Experts opinion:
I love this liner! First, I don’t need to sharpen it, all you do is turn it and the liner comes out! Second, is super super smooth, glides on smoothly, no tugging necessary. Third, there’s a smudger on the other side, smudge the line out for a smoky look! Fourth, it stays on for a long time and you can take it off with a lil makeup remover!
- Mandee, from Vancouver, Canada
Description:
If you are no expert in applying eye makeup, this product may just do the trick for you. You can easily achieve the dusky effect when using this eyeliner to work on your eyes – it’s really easy to apply! There is also a great selection of colors to choose from.
Our Opinion:
Those who have makeup allergies will be glad to know that the Clinique Quickliner for eyes is allergy tested and is 100% fragrance free. The good thing about this product is that the silky formula slinks on to line and define your eyes in the best way possible.
Best Price: $14.50 at Sephora
[...] look does make Fergie’s eyes stand out, but at the same time the eyeliner in the corners of her eyes adds some mystery and tenderness. Perfect for a night [...]
I have really oily skin especially around my eyelids and i have used every type of liquid liner that is “guaranteed” to last.
For example, the first one, make up forever aqua eyes. i have used the set primer and alone and it still bleed and creases and smudges even after letting it dry for 6 minutes.
So i gave up on stick and went to liquid and i use carbon black loreal liquid liner and its good for the price but it smears off and all. The calligraphy seems reliable but i cant go around spending $32 a month on one cosmetic. I use liner almost everyday, so do you have any other alternatives?
to Rebeeziac:
I have pretty oily eye lids too and I’ve been using a Dior eye liner for over a year now (it just doesn’t end, I still have half of this pen, although I sharpen it regularly and use it every single day). I don’t get any smudges, but I only wish they had a deeper black for more expression.
Try it in Sephora and see if it works for you! It was a pretty good investment for me…
same problem here ive used like 15 eyeliners and they all run under my eye and make me look like i havent slept for a month. ive used liquid waterproof, pencil waterproof, mineral with a brush, u name it! best option is Maybelline eye and eyebrow liner (the little red one that comes in wood pencil, the plastic one wont last). Its awsome and stays put. If u need more color (like for night makeup) just turn a lighter on and put the tip of the eye liner for 2 seconds (if u leave it more the tip will melt) then let it cool for 20 seconds apply and Vuala! super black cheap long lasting for oily skin! (the price is like $7 the pack of 2 at any drugstore. Enjoy ladies!
Hey Alix,
Wow haven’t tried that! Thanks for sharing! :)
Hi ladies, I have tried liquid, powder, gel, pencil and nothing lasts 16 hours. I tried the $32 felt tip eyeliner by Hourglass, and it didnt stay on long enough. Dont spend your money on it. It faded after 5 to 6 hours and it flaked and smeared. I gave it a try for a week and I had to return it to Sephora. Same thing with Urban Decays gel liner $25. It faded and it would rub off. I agree with Alix thats the best kept secret, Maybellines red wooden eyeliner stays on for ever as long as you light a match and heat up the tip of the eyeliner for about 2 seconds. Let it cool off for 30 seconds and apply. You can even use it on the inside of your lower lash line and it WONT smear. I have been using it since I was 16 and Im 44. Trends come and go, but this eyeliner stays on.
Ej,
Well I guess if two of you swear by it, it probably does work! Note to self: Must try Maybeline’s red wooden eyeliner. Thanks again! :)