When a Hole is Not a Hole

0
COMMENT

Wandering around in blogville the other day, I ran across a post by an aspiring screenwriter discussing plot holes.

Now, I can't say for 100% sure exactly what a plot hole is but I am pretty sure I know what it isn't.

A plot hole ISN'T an unanswered question.2

That would make it a plot question instead of a hole, don'tcha think?

Wait.

Side street.

Here's something you don't read every day.

"Three penguins were killed by oncoming traffic;

one died in the crash when a truck spilled about two dozen penguins, tropical fish and an octopus onto an east Texas highway near Marshall."

Sometimes, I genuinely worry about these meds they give me for tooth aches.

Okay, where was I?

Oh yes, so, ever the screenwriting sleuth, I called my mother -- who told me that at four o'clock in the morning, she was only qualified to discuss sex, hot flashes, breast implants and lyposuction.

Who else is a gal supposed to turn to with a complicated question?

Couldn't find a Howie Schwabb hotline so I went to Wikepedia which says that:

"A plot hole is a gap in a storyline that goes against the flow of logic set-up by the plot or that undermines the basic premises of the story."2

I know.

I know.

I need to see what my screenwriting books and screenwriting buddies say about it.2

But before I made it to the trunk of books in the garage, I began to wonder if the term "plot hole" was a derivitive of "wormhole" which, in science fiction, is used to bridge the gap between two areas of space or time.

Sounded plausible enough.

But, who to ask?

I called my mother back.

You know, I don't think she was thrilled to hear from me and she didn't believe me about the penguins either.

However, she did give me some information about Schwarzschild wormholes, Einstein-Rosen bridges and some kind of wormhole metric theory that I couldn't quite follow because, come on, it was four o' clock in the morning!

Point.

I always have one.

It's occassionally vague and sometimes involves Smurfs and an ostrich named Curtis who sticks his head in my car window to change the radio station, but I do always have a point.

The point here is that I need to delve deeper into this plot hole issue because it seems to me that the omission of back story or explanation isn't a plot hole unless it causes, you know, a hole!

-- something illogical, irreconcilable or contradictory.

Couldn't a deliberately unanswered question sometimes be clever manipulation used to ignite the viewer's imagination instead of orchestrating it?

Hey.

Good news.

The octopus survived.

Crash of the Penguins - and you thought I was hallucinating.

Explore more ...