--- title: "7 Pros and Cons-Thumb Sucking Vs. Pacifier ..." description: "It Made My Baby Happy; It Helped My Baby Fall Asleep; It Kept My Baby Quiet; The Thumb Never Gets Lost; It Introduces Germs; More ..." url: "https://allwomenstalk.com/7-pros-and-cons-thumb-sucking-vs-pacifier/" category: "lifestyle" last_updated: "2026-06-07" --- # 7 Pros and Cons\-Thumb Sucking Vs. Pacifier ... As a mother of 6 children, and an aunt to 11 great kiddos, I have heard the debate between thumbs and pacifiers between moms, doctors, and dentists. It rages on and on. Is it good, bad, right, or wrong? After real life examples pop up in my house on a day- to -day basis, here is what I have learned from experience ## 1. It Made My Baby Happy ![It Made My Baby Happy](https://resize.allw.mn/1028x0/filters:format(webp)/filters:quality(70)/content/www/2010/10/7-pros-and-cons-thumb-sucking-vs-pacifier/it-made-my-baby-happy_7-pros-and-cons-thumb-sucking-vs-pacifier_500x375.jpg) Photo Credit: [qtjyn_hapi](https://www.flickr.com/photos/24016613@N06/2411913359/in/faves-54085238@N05/) Babies have a natural sucking instinct they need to fulfill. There are a few babies who refuse a paci and their thumb. Half of my babies needed a paci, half of them did not. I found that if I let them satisfy their craving for a paci, they were much happier, as was the rest of the family! ## 2. It Helped My Baby Fall Asleep ![It Helped My Baby Fall Asleep](https://resize.allw.mn/1028x0/filters:format(webp)/filters:quality(70)/content/www/2010/10/7-pros-and-cons-thumb-sucking-vs-pacifier/it-helped-my-baby-fall-asleep_7-pros-and-cons-thumb-sucking-vs-pacifier_500x333.jpg) Photo Credit: [Hamed Saber](https://www.flickr.com/photos/hamed/3065779167/in/faves-54085238@N05/) It isn’t good for babies to fall asleep with a bottle. The milk left in a baby’s mouth can cause problems with their teeth and also presents a chocking hazard. A pacifier, or the baby’s thumb, reduces those problems. Yet, you still have a peaceful baby who loves to sleep. ## 3. It Kept My Baby Quiet ![It Kept My Baby Quiet](https://resize.allw.mn/1028x0/filters:format(webp)/filters:quality(70)/content/www/2010/10/7-pros-and-cons-thumb-sucking-vs-pacifier/it-kept-my-baby-quiet_7-pros-and-cons-thumb-sucking-vs-pacifier_500x318.jpg) Photo Credit: [eperales](https://www.flickr.com/photos/eperales/2504967075/in/faves-54085238@N05/) Whether you are visiting family, friends, or out shopping, there are times when it isn’t convenient to let your little one exercise his or her lungs. By allowing a “binky” your baby will be satisfied and not cry at the most inappropriate times. ## 4. The Thumb Never Gets Lost ![The Thumb Never Gets Lost](https://resize.allw.mn/1028x0/filters:format(webp)/filters:quality(70)/content/www/2010/10/7-pros-and-cons-thumb-sucking-vs-pacifier/the-thumb-never-gets-lost_7-pros-and-cons-thumb-sucking-vs-pacifier_500x333.jpg) Photo Credit: [Mark E](https://www.flickr.com/photos/mark_e/559423126/in/faves-54085238@N05/) If your baby will suck on his fingers of thumb, you never need to stop what you are doing and find that crazy binky. The thumb is always everywhere your baby goes. Never leave home without it again! ## 5. It Introduces Germs _ Photo Credit: Daniel Mosley_ Fingers harbor germs! Pacifiers do too! What do you say to a child who is 5 or 6 when they put their fingers in their mouth? Of course you remind them of the germs they carry around on their fingers. Germs are just as real on toddler’s fingers, and maybe much more. They do not care where their fingers have been or what they have touched. Try telling a two year old his fingers have germs on them! They will look at you like they have no idea what you are talking about. ## 6. It is a Hard Habit to Break ![It is a Hard Habit to Break](https://resize.allw.mn/1028x0/filters:format(webp)/filters:quality(70)/content/www/2010/10/7-pros-and-cons-thumb-sucking-vs-pacifier/it-is-a-hard-habit-to-break_7-pros-and-cons-thumb-sucking-vs-pacifier_500x333.jpg) Photo Credit: [Piulet](https://www.flickr.com/photos/piulet/2835117801/in/faves-54085238@N05/) With a pacifier, you can throw it away, endure a few nights of sleepless nightmares, and that’s the end of it. With a thumb sucker, what are you going to do, cut their thumb off? No! They may suck their thumb longer, but they will eventually outgrow the need. ## 7. Toddlers Shouldn’t Be Allowed a Paci ![Toddlers Shouldn’t Be Allowed a Paci](https://resize.allw.mn/1028x0/filters:format(webp)/filters:quality(70)/content/www/2010/10/7-pros-and-cons-thumb-sucking-vs-pacifier/toddlers-shouldn-t-be-allowed-a-paci_7-pros-and-cons-thumb-sucking-vs-pacifier_498x332.jpg) Photo Credit: [Carlos Porto](https://www.flickr.com/photos/carlosporto/3636404556/in/faves-54085238@N05/) What is the right age to wean a baby from a binky? Really, I feel like that is dependent on the baby and mother. But honestly, a toddler who is 3 or 4 should be weaned. A pacifier interferes with language development and can cause your baby teeth problems. Please, wean then early! So there you have it - My two cents on the pros and cons of “fu-fu” (as mine called them) and thumb sucking! What about you? What are your thoughts? I would love to hear what you have to say. Top Photo Credit: [Voetmann](https://www.flickr.com/photos/voetmann/483638909/) ## Related Posts - [when to start buying maternity clothes](https://money.allwomenstalk.com/ways-to-avoid-buying-maternity-clothes/) - [factors to consider when naming a child](https://parenting.allwomenstalk.com/things-to-consider-before-naming-your-baby/) - [things to consider before having a child](https://parenting.allwomenstalk.com/serious-things-to-consider-before-having-a-baby/) - [how to prepare your body for pregnancy after misca...](https://parenting.allwomenstalk.com/tips-for-preparing-to-get-pregnant-after-miscarriage/) - [body shape of a pregnant woman](https://fashion.allwomenstalk.com/style-tips-for-pregnant-women/) - [stay at home moms business ideas](https://lifestyle.allwomenstalk.com/perfect-mama-home-based-business-ideas/) - [perfect nursery](https://allwomenstalk.com/8-tips-on-creating-the-perfect-nursery-for-your-little-one/) - [how do you tell someone your pregnant](https://parenting.allwomenstalk.com/ways-to-tell-people-you-are-pregnant/) - [newborn preparation](https://parenting.allwomenstalk.com/things-to-do-in-preparation-for-a-baby/) - [pregnant and didnt know it](https://parenting.allwomenstalk.com/things-you-didnt-know-about-pregnancy/) - [7 Ways to Make Your Little One Smile ...](https://parenting.allwomenstalk.com/7-ways-to-make-your-little-one-smile/) - [7 Things to Consider before Buying a Baby Crib ...](https://parenting.allwomenstalk.com/7-things-to-consider-before-buying-a-baby-crib/) ## Site Information - [Main page](https://allwomenstalk.com) - [Contact us](https://allwomenstalk.com/contact.html) - [HTML article](https://allwomenstalk.com/7-pros-and-cons-thumb-sucking-vs-pacifier/)